They say baseball is America’s pastime. (We don’t know who “they” are either. Sorry. We’re working on it.) July marks the middle of a long season for the boys of summer. For us, it’s a good excuse to play a game of “Who Am I?” with some of your favorite players that represent their teams on the diamond. Can you guess who’s who? Check out these pics to find out!

After a long and rain-soaked season, the Major League Baseball playoffs are upon us! Here’s an idea we’d like to pitch you — can you guess who these MLB stars were before they hit it big? (Get it? Pitch? Hit? Please say yes, we’re out of puns.) Check it out!