They had us at hello, Peter Gabriel’s “In Your Eyes” blasting on a boom box, and tugged out heartstrings for a decade… Today, Snakkle looks back on your favorite ‘80s teen crushes. See if you can remember who got your pulse racing over two decades ago (are we that old!?).

It’s been three decades since a group of largely unknown actors burst onto the screen in the now iconic film The Outsiders. Some, like Tom Cruise, have enjoyed major success since they starred in the 1983 hit, while others—Leif Garrett, anyone?—have weathered their fair share of problems. Check out the rising and falling fortunes of the entire cast.