Boy bands—they’re not just pretty faces, are we right? Even though we know you had their mugs plastered all over your walls, notebooks, and lockers growing up. How could you resist swooning to their sweet ballads and rocking out to their hot dance moves? Thanks to the spending power of the American teenager, the men behind the music weren’t mere one-hit wonders, but have they kept their appeal all these years later. Snakkle looks back at ‘N SYNC along with some of your other favorite boy bands, then and now.

Your old flames—you know they’re there. Lurking inside those rolled-up posters in your mother’s basement are some of the hottest boys next door this world has ever seen. Unfurl those posters with pride, ladies and gentlemen, and bask in the glory of Snakkle’s look back at our favorite teen idols!