We’re saddened at the departure of How I Met Your Mother but we’ve had nine seasons that’ve brought us good times at MacLaren’s with our favorite sitcom group of friends, new catchphrases (Legendary!), life theories (the Bro Code!) and had us eagerly awaiting the arrival of the Mother (Cristin Milioti) who did not disappoint. Let’s say farewell to our whiskey swilling, laser tag playing, red cowboy boot wearing group by looking back at their high school pictures. Sadly, none of them had a goth phase like Lily Aldrin.

We were there for their first kisses, and their first… well, “firsts” and all the teen angst-filled love triangles on Dawson’s Creek which aired for six seasons on TV from 1998 – 2003. Whether you were rooting for Joey and Pacey, or Joey and Dawson or Dawson and Jen or Jen and Jack or… [gosh, we’re STILL confused], but Capeside High was just like any other high school: full of little white lies, hard learned life lessons and loves lost and found. Now, 10 years after the show has ended, Snakkle finds out where the talented cast are now, and where they ended up after Dawson’s Creek.

’Tis the season for togetherness, tight-knit families—and trips down memory lane. Ever wondered what these celebrity couples were like before they got together? We’ve got their school-days pics.

Whether these couples remain together or are a thing of the past, we’ll always remember their strange love (and all the tabloid stories that went with it). Check out these vintage pics of weird celebrity couples!

Be afraid! These celebrity ghosts and ghouls wore some fantastically frightening homemade costumes back in high school. Enter if you dare!