When Twin Peaks premiered in 1990, understandably, no one knew what to make of the bizarre and terrifying events and people surrounding the death of Laura Palmer in the sleepy Washington town. Today, the television show has both a cult and critical following and as of this week will be returning to Showtime in 2016, just in time for the 25th anniversary. Take a look at the stars of Twin Peaks before they stepped foot into David Lynch’s foggy nightmare.

We’re saddened at the departure of How I Met Your Mother but we’ve had nine seasons that’ve brought us good times at MacLaren’s with our favorite sitcom group of friends, new catchphrases (Legendary!), life theories (the Bro Code!) and had us eagerly awaiting the arrival of the Mother (Cristin Milioti) who did not disappoint. Let’s say farewell to our whiskey swilling, laser tag playing, red cowboy boot wearing group by looking back at their high school pictures. Sadly, none of them had a goth phase like Lily Aldrin.

Look back on the four big city girls who brought love, sex, and all the in betweens to TV. Find out where they are now!